General — 07 December 2011
Jayalalitha’s letter to Kerala on Mullaperiyar issue; assures the dam is safe

Chennai:  To the people of Kerala, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister J Jayalalithaa has appealed not to fall prey to vested interests on the Mullaperiyar Dam issue.

In a letter to the people of Kerala, Jayalalithaa said yesterday that the Mullaperiyar Dam is well maintained and periodically reinforced, and that fears over the dam are unfounded.

Here’s the full text of the letter:

It has come to my notice that Ayyappa devotees from Tamil Nadu on pilgrimage to Sabarimala have been attacked by their brothers in Kerala. Vehicles bearing Tamil Nadu registration plates are being vandalized. Similarly, Tamil establishments in Kerala and even journalists and professionals from Tamil Nadu who are there on official work are under threat. The reason for this animosity appears to be the dispute between the Governments of Kerala and Tamil Nadu over the Mullai Periyar Dam issue.

I call upon the highly educated and intelligent people of God’s own Country not to fall a prey to the machinations of narrow, vested interests or of unscrupulous anti-social elements and allow their rational minds to be manipulated to indulge in Quixotic acts of wanton mob violence. To me, these violent developments are alarming and based on imaginary, unfounded fears, which have been fuelled by irresponsible positioning by vested political interests.

When a volatile situation has been precipitated, it is but natural that public passions run high. When things are so, it is the responsibility of the protagonists to reach out to the people and place matters in the right perspective. Let me clarify.

There is no justification whatsoever to believe that the Mullai Periyar dam is unsafe or likely to collapse, bringing a deluge upon Idukki and surrounding districts. The dam is well maintained and has been periodically reinforced. Its safety is being constantly monitored and highly qualified and accomplished technical experts, including those nominated by the Supreme Court of India, have repeatedly reiterated that it is absolutely safe. To doubt its safety merely because it is 116 years old is sheer ignorance. Kallanai, or the Grand Anaicut Dam, widely considered to be the oldest dam in the world, built by Karikala Cholan over the River Cauvery, still stands in Tamil Nadu. Built in the second century AD, it is all of 1900 years old and absolutely safe. Kallanai was built with the same surkhi mortar as the Mullai Periyar dam. There is therefore no necessity to dismiss the Mullai Periyar dam as a primitive construction or fear that it would self-destruct due to old age. It was based on the confidence in its longevity that the initial water-sharing agreement entered into between the British Government of the State of Madras and the State of Travancore was for a period of 999 years.

There has been widespread panic in recent times in the wake of a rumour that the dam stands on an earthquake-prone zone. A study of the seismic map of India, which can be easily downloaded by anyone from the internet, clearly shows that the whole of Kerala and most parts of India, including the city of Chennai, come under Seizmic Zone III, which stands for “moderately active”. Tremors, if at all, in Zone III will rarely cross 3 points on the Richter scale. Tremors of 2 to 2.9 intensity on the Richter scale are “generally not felt, but recorded”. Such tremors are taking place every minute all over the world and are mere statistics for the Meteorology Department. Tremors of  3 to 3.9 intensity on the Richter scale are “often felt, but rarely cause damage”. Such tremors are also widespread and no cause for concern. When this is so, there is absolutely no basis for fear that an earthquake will cause the collapse of the existing Mullai Periyar Dam.

These facts are known to all concerned in Kerala as well. Yet, for some vested reasons, they have preferred to allow a fear psychosis bordering on mass hysteria to build up all over the State over the alleged lack of safety of the Mullai Periyar dam. Kerala is Tamil Nadu’s closest neighbour. In fact, till the early 1950s, the two States were one. Malayalees and Tamils share a common linguistic and cultural heritage. There are a large number of Tamils in Kerala. There are an even larger number of Malayalees in Tamil Nadu. And all have lived together all these decades in an admirable display of brotherhood and co-operation. The Government of Tamil Nadu and the people of the State would be the last people on earth who would want devastation to visit their brothers and sisters in Kerala. We would not claim that the Mullai Periyar Dam is safe unless we were absolutely sure of our facts.

I also call upon the media to exercise restraint and report the issue responsibly and objectively.

I also make a fervent appeal to the people of Kerala not to succumb to the machinations of ill-wishers and unscrupulous mischief mongers. Please do not indulge in acts of senseless violence and vandalism over an imaginary non-issue. Please do not destroy the mutual trust, esteem and goodwill that exist between the people of the two States – which have been painstakingly built up, not just over the last six decades, but over centuries. Do not let whipped up passions cloud your reason and better judgement. This is my request to a people whom I have always held in the highest esteem for their intelligence, education, rationality and hard work.  Finally, I also call upon the political class of Tamil Nadu to desist from making inflammatory speeches on the issue, which would vitiate the cordial  relations that exist between the people of the two States.

.

Related Articles

Bala

(6) Readers Comments

  1. Aright madam,

    Replying after reading the technical spec of the DAM work on todays “The Hindu” in your Appeal. My concern is, if this much of strengthening work has been done, why the IIT experts and Roorkee experts are concluding that the DAM is not safe with such a maintenance activity. Whom should we believe? Agreed that our politicians are making the thing worse by creating agitation in public. But will any of you parties will be able to answer when this negligence lead to loss of human lives? Its not the old british time, that people will fighting among themselves for the cause created by british govt. Now public clearly knows to whom they should react. Loss of Human lives will be compensated with lives of the cause makers. Even the most believed life savers can turn against you or close their eyes for the good. So please stop appealing to public and instead collect the facts from the concerned experts and then share us the real situation. Believe me, if your words are from facts, we keralites will be much happy and wish to have such a able CM like you in our state too.

  2. The comparison between Kallanai built by Karikalacholan and Mullaperiyar dam is meaningless. Kallanai has a height of just 18 feet and thus the water mass it blocks is nothing compared to Mullapperiyar’s since the latter is 157 feet high.

  3. People stay in mansions would not understand the consequence and suffering of normal people who stay in that particular location of tamilian and malayalies .. Kerala govt: has nothing to gain politically. Otherwise never Kerala govt: compromise on building new dams on their own expense give enough water . It is bad to bargain normal people life and releasing violence in boards.. as dam stay in Tamil nadu.

  4. Mam..
    Why dont u sit face 2 face and try to make clear your points before the kerala CM and center. i dont think an appeal like this wil loose the tension prevailing here and there. this may be only an attempt to face the growing national support to kerala stand. kerala wil never stop supplying water to TN, they cant..!! we here are meeting our day to day life only with the supply of comodities from TN especialy these said area of TN. so actually water to TN is in turn for Kerala itself rather than allowing it to flow down to arabian sea. A new dam with more capacity can only solve this problem. it can supply more water and power to TN and safe life to Malayali. this can be done even without decommissioning the existing dam. let it serve as long as it can. please do treat this seriously and creatively setting aside the politics. Only Madam you can do it. each n every keralite respect TN, its great culture and personalities as his ELDER brother status,

  5. Let the dam break and kill people .. then let us see what Jaya lalitha & other Tamil people will say..

    they are playing with the lives of millions..

  6. As you can see in the Google Earth, TN is having a broader land area and Kerala is only a having narrow streach from East to West. Moreover the whole of Kerala is densely populated and especially the so called danger zone. The cross distance from the dam to the sea is roughly 50 kms or less and the dam sits on the upper deck of the main districts of Kerala viz; Kottayam, Idukki, Ernakulam & Alleppey. The dam is sitting on the upper deck of these districts at an overall height of above 1500-2000 ft above the sea level. Taking only the height of the dam is immaterial since it is not built in sea level. TN CM should apply some logical thinking while pleading to people of Kerala to remain quiet. Moreover the water from Mullaperiyar is used for irrigation and it is not a source of drinking water. Do the Keralites need to risk their lives for TN to do irrigation. Even today or tomorrow the dam should be rebuilt and it is not going to remain intact till the end of the world, they why not today and save the lives of millions of people. In Cochin we have already constructed alternative bridges since the main bridges called Venduruthy and Thoppumpady which were built in British Era all most at the same time of Mullaperiyar were found to be unsafe to handle heavy traffic. The dam has to withstand 1000 times pressure than a mere Bridge.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*